So I have a decision to make and need some feedback from you. I have the option of either purchasing a used 2011 Matador Red CT with Caramel interior and 14,xxx miles for $23,990 or a 2012 Starfire Pearl CT with black interior with 16,xxx miles for $25,900. both cars have the same options, both one owner and clean carfax. The 2011 is at a VW dealership and the 2012 is a private sale. Just for the sake of argument let's say both cars are in the exact same condition.